The pair used all of their big-hitting experience to steer the Stars to victory with two balls to spare in front of 40,606 fans at the MCG on Saturday.
Maxwell and fellow veteran Hilton Cartwright came to the rescue late after Ben Duckett (67) and Marcus Stoinis (48) fell in quick succession during the power-play following a crucial 83-run partnership.
Game over!— KFC Big Bash League (@BBL) Hilton Cartwright and Glenn Maxwell have sent the MCG into a frenzy! What a win for the @StarsBBL. #BBL14 pic.twitter.com/rMjZbNDK7PJanuary 4, 2025
Maxwell's reverse sweep for six in the 19th off Gurinder Sandhu (3-29) changed the momentum of the match.
Cartwright's giant six from the third ball of the final over then ensured the Stars would record back-to-back wins after starting the season 0-5.
"I've done a lot of work with our batting coach over the last week with my power hitting," Cartwright said.
"He's been pretty cooked at times so it was definitely nice to get some reward out there."
Capping off a horror night for Tom Rogers, the Renegades quick bowled the final over after previously dropping a tough chance off Maxwell (20no).
MAXI-MUM 🙌— KFC Big Bash League (@BBL) @GMaxi_32 with the reverse lap for SIX! #BBL14 pic.twitter.com/zys2SsBaY4January 4, 2025
The matchwinning knock from Cartwright (24no) is more remarkable given he suffered a scary injury in the field at the start of this BBL.
Played on a pitch with more grass on it than is the norm in the BBL, the Renegades weren't able to defend their 7-168 after being sent in to bat.
The Renegades were sitting on top of the table, but three-straight losses leaves them 2-4 and in a real battle to qualify for finals.
They have concerns with the form of young blaster Jake Fraser-McGurk at the top of the order.
After dominating in the Indian Premier League last year, Fraser-McGurk has struggled for runs all season, making just 67 of them across the first six games of this BBL.
The BBL run of outs continues for Australian T20 player and IPL star Jake Fraser-McGurk (James Ross/AAP PHOTOS)
The 22-year-old, who played for Australia as recently as November, missed the first four balls of his innings before holing out for 12.
Australian white-ball spinner Adam Zampa was booed by the Stars crowd, who he played for up until last season.
Young English star Jacob Bethell (49) and veteran Jono Wells (45) were the Renegades' best with the bat, putting on a 71-run partnership.
Mirroring some incidents in the ongoing Border-Gavaskar Test series, TV umpire Simon Lightbody took almost five minutes to give Star batter Dan Lawrence out after the Renegades were convinced the Englishman had hit the ball.
Fraser-McGurk said he would have gone "bananas" if Lawrence wasn't dismissed.
Cartwright said Lawrence told the players he had hit it and "the right decision was made".